As one who has both, I can tell you the two have distinctly different characteristics. The one thing that Tesla is good for is that there is no shifting delay and the torque is on demand. Having said that, my 55 when it into its torque curve absolutely destroys almost any other Tesla. The only Tesla that you need to actually consider a worthy challenger would be the plaid S with the top speed of 200 miles an hour, and when it comes to handling there is no Tesla that even begins to be in the same class as the 55 that I have.